Posted March 19, 2025

Is Your Home an Unsellable ‘Rogue Home’? Here’s How to Fix It

Selling a home can be an exciting yet challenging process. For some homeowners, however, what starts as an optimistic sale quickly turns into frustration when their property lingers on the market without any offers. If your home has been listed for months without serious interest, it may have become a “rogue home”—a property that buyers actively avoid.

But what exactly makes a home unsellable? More importantly, what can you do to turn things around?

A rogue home is a property that has, for one reason or another, failed to attract buyers despite being in a reasonably active market. This could be due to an overpriced listing, poor marketing strategy, lack of aesthetic appeal, or even hidden defects that make buyers wary. The longer a home sits unsold, the less attractive it becomes in the eyes of potential buyers, creating a cycle that can be difficult to break.

For South Australians trying to sell a home, understanding what turns buyers away is the first step to reviving interest and securing a sale. In this guide, we’ll explore the most common reasons a home becomes a rogue property, how to diagnose if your home falls into this category, and—most importantly—how to fix it.

Whether you’re looking to adjust your price, enhance your home’s presentation, or overhaul your marketing strategy, this article will provide practical and effective solutions to help your property regain traction in the South Australian real estate market.

Let’s start by identifying what makes a home unsellable.

What Makes a Home Unsellable? Common Causes of a ‘Rogue Home’

If your home has been sitting on the market for months without serious offers, it’s important to identify the root cause. In South Australia’s real estate market, homes that fail to attract buyers often share one or more of the following issues:

1. Overpricing

One of the most common reasons a home struggles to sell is pricing it too high. While every seller wants to maximise their return, unrealistic expectations can scare away potential buyers. Properties priced above comparable homes in the area often sit stagnant, leading to price reductions later—by which time buyers may assume something is wrong with the home.

2. Poor Presentation

First impressions matter. A cluttered, outdated, or neglected home can turn buyers away instantly. Common presentation issues include:

Dated décor or bold colour schemes that don’t appeal to the masses.
Excessive personalisation (such as family photos or unique design choices).
Lack of cleanliness, bad odours, or visible signs of neglect.

3. Bad Listing Photos

With most buyers browsing homes online first, high-quality photos and virtual tours are crucial. Dark, blurry, or poorly staged photos can make even a great home seem unappealing.

4. Maintenance or Structural Issues

Buyers are hesitant to take on a property with significant repair needs. Issues such as leaky roofs, outdated wiring, plumbing problems, or pest infestations can deter offers.

5. Poor Marketing or Limited Exposure

If your home isn’t reaching the right buyers, it won’t sell. A weak listing description, lack of digital marketing, or targeting the wrong audience can all contribute to a home being overlooked.

Now that we’ve identified the common causes, let’s look at how to determine whether your property has become a rogue home.

How to Identify if Your Home is a ‘Rogue Home’

If your home has been sitting on the market for longer than expected, you may be wondering whether it has become a rogue home. Identifying the warning signs early can help you take corrective action before your property becomes permanently overlooked. Here’s how to assess whether your home has stalled in the South Australian real estate market.

1. Time on Market: How Long is Too Long?

In a balanced market, most well-priced and well-presented homes in South Australia should sell within four to six weeks. If your home has been on the market for months with little interest, it’s a sign something is wrong. Properties that sit unsold for too long often develop a negative stigma, with buyers assuming there’s an issue—even if there isn’t one.

2. Lack of Showings or Low Buyer Interest

Are you getting very few inquiries, home viewings, or offers? If buyers are not booking inspections or are walking away without making an offer, your listing may not be standing out.

3. Consistently Negative Feedback from Buyers or Agents

Pay attention to what buyers and agents are saying. Common red flags include comments like:

“The price is too high for what it is.”
“It needs too much work.”
“The layout doesn’t work for me.”

4. Poor Online Performance

Check your listing’s engagement on realestate.com.au, Domain, or social media. If views and clicks are low, it means buyers are scrolling past your property.

If your home meets one or more of these criteria, it’s time to take action. In the next section, we’ll explore proven strategies to revive buyer interest and get your home sold.

Strategic Fixes: How to Revive Buyer Interest in Your Home

If your home has become a rogue home, don’t panic—there are proven strategies to reignite buyer interest and get your property back on track. Here’s how to make your home more appealing, marketable, and ultimately, sellable.

1. Adjust the Price Strategically

If your home is overpriced, the best way to generate new interest is by re-evaluating your asking price. Work with your agent to compare recent sales in your area and adjust the price to align with market conditions. However, avoid multiple small reductions—this can make buyers think you’re desperate. Instead, one well-calculated price drop can attract fresh attention.

2. Improve Your Home’s Presentation

A home that looks clean, fresh, and move-in ready is far more appealing to buyers. Key improvements include:

Decluttering – Remove excess furniture and personal items to create a spacious feel.
Painting – Neutral tones like white or light grey make spaces look bigger and brighter.
Landscaping – A well-maintained front yard boosts curb appeal and makes a great first impression.

3. Enhance Your Online Listing

If your home isn’t getting attention online, consider professional real estate photography or even a video walkthrough. A strong, engaging listing description also makes a difference—highlight key features and lifestyle benefits.

4. Refresh Your Marketing Strategy

Sometimes, the problem isn’t the home—it’s how it’s being marketed. Your agent may need to:

Target a different buyer demographic (e.g., first-home buyers, downsizers, or investors).
Expand marketing efforts to social media, email campaigns, and real estate networks.

By making these changes, you can transform a stale listing into a desirable property. But if these adjustments aren’t enough, it might be time for a more drastic approach—like relisting or repositioning your sale strategy. Let’s explore that next.

Should You Relist or Make Bigger Changes?

If your home remains unsold after adjusting the price and improving its presentation, you may need to take more significant action. In some cases, relaunching your listing with a fresh strategy can make all the difference. Here’s what to consider:

1. When to Take the Listing Down and Relaunch

If your property has been sitting on the market for several months with little interest, removing it from listings for a short period and relaunching later can reset buyer perceptions. A “new listing” attracts more attention than one that has been sitting unsold. Use this break to make necessary improvements and reintroduce your home with fresh marketing.

2. Change Your Sales Approach

If your home isn’t selling through a private treaty listing, consider alternative sales methods:

Auction: Creates urgency and can drive up competition. Ideal for homes in high-demand areas.
Off-market sales: Attracts serious buyers without the stigma of a long time on market.

3. Invest in Bigger Renovations

If your home has major flaws—like outdated kitchens, bathrooms, or structural concerns—targeted renovations may be necessary. Consider:

Kitchen and bathroom updates (biggest return on investment).
New flooring or modern lighting to refresh interiors.
Energy-efficient improvements (solar panels, insulation) to appeal to modern buyers.

4. Work with a New Real Estate Agent

If your current agent isn’t delivering results, it might be time to switch. Look for an agent who specialises in your area and has a proven track record of selling similar properties.

By making these larger adjustments, you can turn an unsellable home into a sought-after property. But how can you prevent your home from becoming a rogue listing in the future? Let’s discuss long-term strategies next.

Long-Term Prevention: Avoiding the ‘Rogue Home’ Trap in the Future

If you’ve had a tough time selling your home, the best thing you can do—whether now or for future property sales—is to learn from the experience. Taking the right steps from the beginning can help ensure your home never becomes a rogue home again.

1. Price It Right from Day One

Setting the correct price at the start is crucial. Overpricing leads to buyer hesitation, while underpricing can mean leaving money on the table. Work with a real estate agent who understands the South Australian market, conducts thorough comparative market analysis (CMA), and sets a price that’s competitive yet attractive.

2. Stay on Top of Home Maintenance

Many rogue homes struggle to sell because they have accumulated maintenance issues. Prevent this by keeping up with:

Roof and gutter checks
Plumbing and electrical updates
Garden and landscaping upkeep
Repainting when needed

A well-maintained home is easier to sell, as buyers see it as a move-in-ready property rather than a project.

3. Stage and Present Your Home Properly

Buyers need to visualise themselves living in the space. Before listing, ensure your home is:

Clutter-free and depersonalised
Freshly painted in neutral tones
Well-lit with inviting interiors

Professional staging can help maximise the home’s appeal and minimise flaws.

4. Adapt to Market Trends

Real estate markets fluctuate, and buyer expectations change. Stay informed about what buyers are looking for and adjust accordingly—whether it’s eco-friendly features, smart home technology, or modern open-plan layouts.

By implementing these strategies, you can future-proof your property and ensure a smoother sale process next time. Now, let’s wrap things up with some final takeaways.

Turning a Rogue Home into a Sold Home

If your home has been sitting on the market with little interest, it’s important to take action sooner rather than later. A rogue home isn’t unsellable—it simply needs the right adjustments to attract buyers. By identifying the root causes, making strategic fixes, and potentially relaunching your listing, you can turn things around and secure a successful sale.

The most common culprits behind an unsellable home—overpricing, poor presentation, low-quality marketing, or maintenance issues—can all be addressed with the right approach. A price adjustment, fresh marketing strategy, and small but effective improvements like repainting, decluttering, and staging can significantly boost buyer interest. If your home still isn’t selling, consider a more drastic approach, such as switching sales methods, investing in targeted renovations, or even working with a new real estate agent.

Looking forward, the key to avoiding a rogue home situation is proper preparation. Pricing your property correctly from the beginning, keeping up with regular maintenance, and ensuring your home is well-presented will help you sell faster and for a better price.

If you’re struggling to sell your home in South Australia, Broadland Estates can help. Our expert team understands the local market and can provide the right strategy to get your home sold. Contact us today for a consultation and let’s get your property moving in the right direction!

Cart