Can Real Estate Agents in South Australia Lie About Offers? An Ethical and Legal Examination


In the dynamic world of real estate transactions, trust and transparency stand as the bedrock of successful dealings. For many, buying or selling property is among the most significant financial decisions they will make. This process often involves reliance on real estate agents to act as intermediaries who facilitate these transactions with integrity. A common concern that surfaces in this realm is whether agents can misrepresent information, specifically regarding offers on properties. This article delves into the ethical and legal landscape governing real estate agents in South Australia, focusing on their obligations to truthfully communicate offers between parties.


The Legal Framework Governing Real Estate Agents in South Australia


In South Australia, the conduct of real estate agents is strictly regulated under the South Australian Land and Business (Sale and Conveyancing) Act 1994 and the Agents Registration Act 1996. These laws are designed to ensure that agents conduct their business with honesty, fairness, and transparency. Specifically, they are prohibited from engaging in misleading or deceptive conduct, which includes lying about the existence, nature, or details of offers made on properties.


Agents are required to act in the best interests of their clients while also treating all parties involved in a transaction fairly. This includes providing accurate information to potential buyers and sellers. Misrepresenting an offer, whether by inflating the price to encourage a higher counteroffer or by denying the existence of an offer to manipulate a sale, can lead to severe penalties. These range from fines to the suspension or revocation of the agent’s license, highlighting the seriousness with which these matters are treated.


Ethical Standards and Industry Practices


Beyond legal obligations, real estate agents in South Australia are also bound by ethical guidelines established by industry bodies, such as the Real Estate Institute of South Australia (REISA). These guidelines emphasize professional conduct, honesty, and the duty to act in the clients’ best interests at all times.


Ethical standards serve as a moral compass for agents, guiding them to make decisions that uphold the integrity of the real estate profession. These standards explicitly condemn the act of lying about offers, reinforcing the expectation that agents facilitate transactions with the utmost honesty.


Consequences of Misrepresenting Offers


The repercussions of an agent lying about offers extend beyond legal penalties. Such actions can erode trust between buyers, sellers, and their agents, damaging the agent’s reputation and potentially leading to loss of business. For sellers, misinformation about offers can result in financial losses or missed opportunities. Buyers, on the other hand, may end up overpaying or losing confidence in the purchasing process.


Hypothetical scenarios illustrate the gravity of these consequences. For instance, an agent falsely claiming multiple competing offers may prompt a buyer to increase their bid unnecessarily, or a seller might accept a lower offer under the false belief that no better options exist.


Protecting Yourself as a Buyer or Seller


To safeguard against misinformation, buyers and sellers are encouraged to take proactive steps. Direct communication with the selling agent and requesting to see offers in writing can provide tangible proof of the offers’ existence and details. Additionally, seeking independent legal advice before making any decisions based on an agent’s information can further protect parties from potential misrepresentation.


Real estate agents in South Australia are legally and ethically obligated to truthfully communicate about offers, ensuring that the property transaction process is conducted with integrity and transparency. The legal and ethical frameworks in place are designed to protect all parties involved, maintaining trust in the real estate market. Buyers and sellers are advised to remain vigilant, informed, and to seek verification of claims made during the transaction process. By understanding their rights and the duties of real estate agents, individuals can navigate the property market more confidently and securely.




For the purposes of this article, references to the South Australian Land and Business (Sale and Conveyancing) Act 1994, Land Agents Regulations 2010, and REISA guidelines have been generalized. Readers seeking specific legal advice or detailed guidelines should consult the actual legislation or contact REISA directly.


Recommended Posts